– SNJ Today – February 19, 2025
When it comes to rating the best pizza in South Jersey, the truth is—it’s almost impossible to pick just one winner; you’re that spoiled for choice.
You’ll find places that stick to tradition, serving up classic, old-school pies that remind you why you fell in love with pizza in the first place.
Others get creative with flavors, throwing in everything from spicy honey to gourmet cheeses, turning a simple pizza into a whole new experience.
And let’s be honest—when the pizza is this good, how do you even begin to choose?
Well, every year, we’re proud to take on that challenge.
We round up the top pizza spots across Burlington, Camden, Cumberland, and Gloucester counties and put them to the ultimate test.
Which place has the best crust? The richest sauce? The perfect cheese-to-topping ratio?
The competition is always fierce, and this year is no different.
So, who’s taking the crown this year?
Let’s dig in and find out who’s serving up the absolute best pizza in South Jersey!
1. Santucci’s Original Square Pizza, Sewell
Let’s start with one of the most recommended pizza spots in South Jersey: Santucci’s Original Square Pizza.
These guys do things a little differently. They put the cheese under the sauce, which totally changes the way their pizza tastes and feels, much like a Chicago deep dish pie.
Instead of biting into a layer of melted cheese first, you get hit with their bold, tangy tomato sauce right away.
The cheese underneath melts perfectly into the crust, creating a super gooey, flavorful base that’s very different from a regular pizza.
It’s crispy but still soft inside, and the square shape gives it an old-school, homemade feel.
Santucci’s isn’t new to the pizza game—they’ve been making their famous square pies for over 60 years.
People who love their pizza say it’s totally addictive, and once you try it, it’s hard to go back to the usual style.
If you like trying something different that still feels classic, this is a spot you should definitely check out.